The following article appeared in The Pain Practitioner- The Journal of the American Academy Of Pain Management
Alternative Treatment Options for the Management of Diabetic Neuropathy
Volume 22, Number 1, Spring 2012
According to the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, approximately 60%-70% of people with diabetes have some form of neuropathy (1). Many of these patients are treated by a wide variety of prescription medications including anticonvulsants, antidepressants, and analgesics. These medications may be effective in relieving neuropathic pain; however, many patients report side effects that make the drugs difficult to tolerate. For example, commonly prescribed anticonvulsant drugs often result in drowsiness, difficulty concentrating, confusion, and weight gain. In addition, patients with neuropathy usually have existing medical problems and are already taking other medications. They may be resistant to taking even more medication and seek treatment alternatives. The following case presentation illustrates that there are viable, alternative treatments for diabetic neuropathy that should be considered when traditional medications are not an option.
Case history
Tim is a 61-year-old man with Type 1 diabetes. He was diagnosed with diabetes at age 36, and he currently takes Lantus (insulin glargine). He has severe peripheral arterial disease and has undergone three vascular reconstruction procedures for femoral occlusion. In 2003 he developed a non-healing ulceration on the right foot. He was given 75 hyperbaric treatments at Long Beach Memorial Medical Center. The limb was salvaged, but amputation of a toe was necessary.
Tim first presented to my office in September 2005 complaining of numbness and a dull ache and “pins and needle” sensations in his feet. He related that symptoms were worse when standing while at work as an elementary school teacher and also at bedtime. He was evaluated by a team of specialists including an endocrinologist, a vascular surgeon, and a neurologist. Tim was diagnosed with diabetic neuropathy and was placed on gabapentin 300 mg (2), three times a day. He had difficulty tolerating the medication, reporting that he experienced extreme fatigue. Other medications were prescribed, including pregabalin (3) and duloxetine (4), however, the patient could not tolerate these medications either. Diagnostic testing confirmed diabetic neuropathy characterized by loss of light touch perception, using the Semmes-Weinstein 10-g monofilament, and loss of vibration perception, measured with a 128-Hz tuning fork.
An alternative treatment plan was instituted using iontophoresis and microcurrent electrical therapy together with a self-contained garment system.
Non-invasive treatment using iontophoresis
Iontophoresis is a non-invasive method of delivering drugs into the body using direct electrical current. A direct current facilitates the transdermal delivery of local ionizable anesthetic and anti-inflammatory agents.
Iontophoresis is based on the electrical magnetic principle that opposite poles attract and like poles repel. When a solution consisting of specific drugs of one polarity is placed on a skin patch with the same polarity as the energy source, the solution is repelled and is driven transdermally through the skin.
Medications carrying a positive charge are drawn to cathode electrodes and repelled by anode electrodes, while negatively charged medication compounds display the reverse behavior (5). Whereas iontophoresis was initially thought to drive the ions through the skin and into underlying tissue, recent research suggests that it promotes transdermal penetration by increasing the permeability of the stratum corneum (6).
Physical therapy clinics are generally equipped to administer medications via iontophoresis, but the patient must bring the prescribed ionic medication solution, which is formulated by a compound pharmacist. When selecting the drugs for this treatment it is important to be aware of the polarity of the drugs selected (7). For example, lidocaine hydrochloride is a positively charged medication and thus the power source needs to set to a positive polarity to deliver the drug through the skin. Other positively charged medications include hydrocortisone and magnesium sulfate; negatively charged medications used for chronic pain include dexamethasone and salicylates.
Contradindications to the use of iontophoresis include its use in individuals with a cardiac pacemaker or other electrically sensitive implanted device, or during pregnancy. It should not be used when there is a known sensitivity or an adverse reaction to the drugs to be administered, or an adverse reaction to the application of electrical current. The skin patches should not be used on damaged skin or recent scar tissue, and they should not be applied to the temporal region, anterior cervical region, or carotid sinuses. Care should be taken to prevent skin damage due to adhesive irritants used on electrodes and to prevent exposure to the accumulated pH changes that may occur beneath the electrode (6,8).
Tim’s treatment course
The drugs chosen for Tim’s treatment were gabapentin 4% concentration and ketamine 2% concentration in a clear solution. He was scheduled for three treatments per week for eight weeks. Following each treatment, he received a light foot and leg massage. Additionally he received a conductive sock garment for home use along with a microcurrent electrotherapy device. This system differs from a traditional TENS unit by emitting a smaller electrical charge that mitigates pain as opposed to TENS, which blocks pain signals. The sock allows treatment to be given over a greater surface area.
The contraindications for the garment system are similar to those for TENs therapy. The garment should not be used in patients who have a cardiac pacemaker or other electrically sensitive implanted device; it should not be used during pregnancy; it should be used cautiously in patients with a spinal cord stimulator or an intrathecal pump; and the electrodes should not be placed on irritated skin.
Tim received two socks since his condition was bilateral and symmetrical. Initial treatment was started in October 2005. The patient noted improvement after six iontophoresis treatments and application of the socks on a regular basis. He related that he experienced fewer “pins and needles” sensations in his feet, and he was more comfortable at work and at bedtime. He continued to have numbness in his feet, and on physical examination it was noted that he had absent pain-touch and vibratory sensations. Currently, Tim continues to be seen on an as needed basis. As with most patients with neuropathy, he has periods of flare-ups and remissions. He states that the treatments and the home device are helpful in relieving discomfort. Other than the treatments described he takes no medication for neuropathic pain.
Conclusion
Tim’s case illustrates the many challenges faced by health care professionals when treating diabetic neuropathy. Like Tim, many patients have difficulty tolerating the various medications used in the treatment of neuropathic pain. In formulating a treatment plan, the social implications must also be considered. For example, Tim needs to be alert and highly functional as he is responsible for the care of elementary school children. Tim is satisfied with his treatment at the Foot Pain Center. Although he continues to experience some neuropathic pain and numbness in his feet, he relates that his quality of life has improved. He is able to continue teaching and he takes no additional medication for neuropathic pain.
MARC SPITZ, DPM, graduated from the California College of Podiatric Medicine in June 1973 and did his podiatric residency at Magnolia Hospital, Long Beach, California, from July 1973 to July 1974. He has been in private practice in Seal Beach, California, from 1974 to present and has had hospital privileges at Fountain Valley Regional Hospital, Fountain Valley, California from 1976 to present. Soon after establishing a private practice, Dr. Spitz noted ever increasing numbers of patients presenting with peripheral neuropathy symptoms, prompting him to establish the Foot Pain Center in Seal Beach focusing on peripheral neuropathy. Being the group leader for the Orange County Neuropathy Support Group has afforded him with the opportunity to interact and understand the challenges faced by people who suffer from neuropathy. He is the co-author of The Numb Foot Book: How to treat and prevent peripheral neuropathy and has established Footpaincenter.com, a website with information, articles, and additional resources on the condition.